Mastering Asymmetric Risk: Noah Birk’s Insights from Straight Up Chicago Investor Podcast

In a recent interview with the Straight Up Chicago Investor podcast, Kiser Group’s Noah Birk shared valuable insights on a key concept in real estate negotiation: asymmetric risk. His approach provides a strategic framework that can guide both buyers and sellers through the often emotional and complex process of closing a deal. Here’s a breakdown of the conversation and how Noah applies asymmetric risk in real estate negotiations to maximize success.

Listen to the Full audio here: 

What is Asymmetric Risk?

Asymmetric risk, as Noah explains, is about positioning yourself in situations where the downside is minimal, but the potential reward is significant. This concept applies across life, business, and especially in real estate. When negotiating, the goal is to minimize your exposure to risks while keeping yourself open to significant rewards—whether that’s securing a deal, maximizing sale price, or managing buyer-seller relations.

The Importance of Focus During Negotiation

Noah highlights that in the early stages of a deal, parties often approach the process logically—determining price, earnest money, and timelines with clear thinking. However, as the deal progresses, fatigue sets in, and emotions can cloud judgment. This is when people start focusing on “winning” small battles (like extensions or earnest money negotiations) and lose sight of the bigger picture: closing the deal.

According to Noah, it’s essential to keep your eye on the ultimate goal—successfully closing the deal. By concentrating on Tier 1 priorities, such as price and deal completion, you avoid getting sidetracked by smaller, less impactful issues.

Negotiation Pitfalls to Avoid

One common pitfall Noah discusses is when sellers let emotions take over, especially after multiple extensions or small requests from buyers. He stresses the importance of maintaining perspective. For example, if a buyer asks for a few months of old water bills, a seller might feel frustrated and think, “Just buy the building!” However, refusing a simple request like that could jeopardize a multi-million-dollar deal. Instead, Noah encourages sellers to assess whether a minor inconvenience, like finding old documents, is worth risking the entire transaction.

This mindset applies to buyers as well. Noah shared a personal experience of being caught between his set price for a building and the seller’s higher ask. In such moments, it’s important to take a step back and ask: “Will I regret losing this deal over a relatively small amount?” Balancing logic and emotion is key to avoiding unnecessary risks in negotiations.

The Role of Velocity in a Deal

Another critical factor in deal-making is the speed at which the process unfolds. As Noah points out, time can kill deals. If you’re on the buying side, making quick, decisive actions—like submitting earnest money promptly—sets the tone for how the deal will progress. By establishing a smooth process from the start, buyers position themselves favorably for future asks, such as requests for credits or concessions later in the deal.

Conversely, dragging your feet can frustrate sellers and decrease the likelihood of favorable outcomes as the deal moves forward. Noah emphasizes that clear communication and swift actions can help avoid unnecessary friction and keep the deal on track.

Striking the Balance: When to Stand Firm

While Noah advocates for minimizing unnecessary risks, he acknowledges that there is always a Gray area in negotiations. At some point, buyers and sellers need to assess their non-negotiables—those points they are unwilling to compromise on. However, it’s crucial to constantly re-evaluate whether holding firm on a particular point is truly worth jeopardizing the deal. In many cases, letting go of minor preferences can lead to a greater overall reward.

The Role of Brokers: Keeping Emotions in Check

One of the podcast’s closing remarks emphasizes the broker’s role in keeping emotions out of the deal. Buyers and sellers can easily get caught up in personal stakes, but a broker’s job is to keep everyone focused on the goal: closing the transaction. By maintaining a level head and focusing on the bigger picture, brokers can help clients avoid unnecessary conflict and stay on track for a successful closing.